Selecting Your Subject

Suggested Duration: 5 Hours

"There is no such thing as a life that is simple or a life that is unconstructed. The moment a life is written, it becomes a story."

Adapted from Hermione Lee (Biographer and Academic)

Welcome to the Biography Unit! For the next few weeks, you will be reading a full-length biography or autobiography of a person of interest.

But before you settle on one, you need to shop around. Instead of just picking the first book you find, you are going to step into the role of a literary critic. You will investigate five different biography options, create a custom rating system, and produce a series of short-form, social-media style video reviews for each.


Finding a Story: Suggested Canadian Lives

While you can choose subjects from anywhere in the world, we strongly encourage you to include Canadian figures in your search. Exploring a Canadian life offers a unique opportunity to engage with local history, cultural diversity, and the complex narratives that shape our national identity.

Here are a few compelling Canadian subjects and books to consider adding to your list of options:

  • Terry Fox (e.g., Terry by Douglas Coupland): A national icon of resilience and selflessness. Coupland’s biography uses family photos and memories to examine how a young athlete from Port Coquitlam became an enduring mythic symbol of Canadian identity.
  • Viola Desmond (e.g., Viola Desmond: Her Life and Times by Graham Reynolds): Her act of defiance in a New Glasgow movie theater sparked a major civil rights movement in Canada. This biography places her personal life within the broader context of Black Canadian history and resistance.
  • Ken Dryden (e.g., The Game by Ken Dryden): An autobiography/memoir that uses a single week in the life of a goalie to reflect on Canadian culture, the nature of celebrity, pressure, and the transition out of youth.
  • Buffy Sainte-Marie (e.g., Buffy Sainte-Marie: The Authorized Biography by Andrea Warner): A pioneering Cree singer-songwriter, activist, and educator. Her life story offers a deep dive into the intersection of music, Indigenous rights, and corporate censorship.
  • Chris Hadfield (e.g., An Astronaut's Guide to Life on Earth by Chris Hadfield): An autobiography detailing how a kid from a southern Ontario corn farm became the commander of the International Space Station, framing a life through the lens of extreme preparation, humility, and curiosity.
  • Oscar Peterson (e.g., Oscar Peterson: The Will to Improvise by Gene Lees): A legendary jazz pianist from Montreal’s Little Burgundy neighborhood who rose to international fame. His biography explores the golden age of jazz, technical mastery, and the challenges faced by Black musicians in Canada and the United States.
💡

Have other subjects in mind? Look into biographies of Canadian authors, politicians, activists, athletes, or international figures who fascinate you. You're not limited to this list: Feel free to explore and choose someone you connect with!


Investigate Your Options

Your task is to preview 5 different biography/autobiography options and evaluate them using a rating system of your own creation. Use online reviews, YouTube/Social Media reviews, or Gemini suggetions to get a sense of what some books would be like.

Design Your Value System

You must define your own criteria for what makes a biography "good" or "suitable" for an Ontario Grade 12 student. You will rate books on a scale of 1 to 5 stars, but you get to make up your own values and explain what those scores represent.

Think about the "strategic" aspects of the writing. Don't just focus on whether the subject is famous. Think about how the book is constructed:

  • Meta-Transparency: Does the biographer openly discuss their sources and acknowledge gaps in their research, or do they write like an all-knowing narrator?
  • Narrative Framing: Does the author shape the subject's life into a dramatic, readable story, or does it feel like a dry list of dates and genealogy?
  • Linguistic Complexity: Is the language and style of the text appropriately challenging for a Grade 12 university-bound student?
  • Lived Perspective: Is it an autobiography (written by the subject) or an external biography? How does the author's relationship to the subject affect the representation of their life?

Declare a Winner

Choose the book with the highest score. You may need to revise your scoring system to rig the results: A small gimmick to engage people in the videos you will make in the next step is ok, but generally try to demonstrate that you're engaging seriously with the content.

Deliverable:

📤

Score Card

Make a Google Doc assigning scores from 1-5 to each category for each book. You will submit a markdown file, so don't use tables or anything fancy: just write a heading for each book and the category and score on new lines. Based on your system, select a winner.


Snappy Social Media Reviews

For each of the 5 books you investigate, record a short, social-media style video review. Imagine you are posting this to TikTok, Instagram Reels, or YouTube Shorts.

  • The Hook: Start with a compelling quote, a surprising fact about the subject, etc.
  • Speculative Review: Spend 30 seconds commenting on the things other people have said about the text and why you like that or not. Refer to your scoring system.
  • Your Score: Give the book a rating from 1 to 5 based on your custom value system and explain why it earned that rating.

Deliverables:

📤

Five Snappy Reviews

Submit all of your reviews (about 1 minute each/5 mins total) as one video file. Remember to continue to include technical stretch goals in your video productions.

Assessment

Pre-Submission

Before you submit, please complete the Pre-Submission Self-Assessment.

What to Turn In

  • 📤

    Score Card (Google Doc)

  • 📤

    Five Social Media Reviews (video)

💡 A Different Way to Learn

Async Academy courses are inquiry-based. There are no rote answer keys or multiple-choice worksheets here. You learn by exploring, questioning, and building projects you care about.

Because your discovery path is completely unique, you need a human sounding board. Enroll to submit your projects and get personalized video feedback from an Ontario Certified Teacher to guide your work.

Learning Goals

We are learning to:

  • 🎯

    Create a custom evaluation framework to analyze and rate literary biographies

  • 🎯

    Evaluate five different biography or autobiography options using your custom criteria, focusing on their suitability for an Ontario student

  • 🎯

    Analyze the "meta" writing of each text—how the author selects details, frames the subject, and constructs a narrative out of a life

  • 🎯

    Communicate concise, engaging critical reviews using short-form digital media conventions

Success Criteria

I can:

  • Define a unique value system with clear criteria for rating books from 1 to 5 stars

    Expectations Covered: W1
  • Select and research 5 different biography or autobiography options, including at least one Canadian suggestion

    Expectations Covered: RLS1
  • Create 5 social-media style videos (under 1 minute each) that hook the audience, evaluate the text, and give a 1-5 star rating

    Expectations Covered: OC1, OC2, MS3
  • Incorporate "meta" observations in each review (e.g., author's relationship to the subject, narrative voice, selectivity, and bias)

    Expectations Covered: RLS2, RLS3
  • Justify your final selection of the book you will read based on your evaluation results

    Expectations Covered: W2

Rubric

Category Level 4 Level 3 Level 2 Level 1
Knowledge / Understanding
How well does the student demonstrate understanding of biography/autobiography conventions and how they apply to suitability for a target student audience?
Demonstrates a thorough and nuanced understanding of biography conventions and student suitability Demonstrates a considerable understanding of biography conventions and student suitability Demonstrates some understanding of biography conventions and student suitability Demonstrates limited understanding of biography conventions and student suitability
Thinking / Inquiry
How effectively does the student design a custom rating framework (value system) and integrate critical "meta" thinking about authorial choices and narrative construction in their reviews?
Formulates a highly sophisticated, original value system and performs deep, insightful "meta" analysis of the texts Formulates a clear value system and performs detailed "meta" analysis of the texts Formulates a basic value system and performs some "meta" analysis of the texts Formulates a weak or unclear value system and performs limited "meta" analysis
Communication
How clearly, dynamically, and engagingly does the student present their reviews across five short social-media style videos (1 minute or less each)?
Delivers highly engaging, polished, and concise video reviews with exceptional pacing and clarity Delivers clear and engaging video reviews with good pacing and clarity Delivers video reviews with some engagement, clarity, or organization Delivers video reviews with limited clarity, poor pacing, or minimal engagement
Application
How effectively does the student apply their custom rating criteria consistently across 5 different biography/autobiography options to select a final text?
Applies the rating criteria with a high degree of consistency and effectiveness across all 5 options Applies the rating criteria with considerable consistency and effectiveness across most options Applies the rating criteria with some consistency across the options Applies the rating criteria with limited consistency
Knowledge / Understanding
Criteria: How well does the student demonstrate understanding of biography/autobiography conventions and how they apply to suitability for a target student audience?
Level 4

Demonstrates a thorough and nuanced understanding of biography conventions and student suitability

Level 3

Demonstrates a considerable understanding of biography conventions and student suitability

Level 2

Demonstrates some understanding of biography conventions and student suitability

Level 1

Demonstrates limited understanding of biography conventions and student suitability

Thinking / Inquiry
Criteria: How effectively does the student design a custom rating framework (value system) and integrate critical "meta" thinking about authorial choices and narrative construction in their reviews?
Level 4

Formulates a highly sophisticated, original value system and performs deep, insightful "meta" analysis of the texts

Level 3

Formulates a clear value system and performs detailed "meta" analysis of the texts

Level 2

Formulates a basic value system and performs some "meta" analysis of the texts

Level 1

Formulates a weak or unclear value system and performs limited "meta" analysis

Communication
Criteria: How clearly, dynamically, and engagingly does the student present their reviews across five short social-media style videos (1 minute or less each)?
Level 4

Delivers highly engaging, polished, and concise video reviews with exceptional pacing and clarity

Level 3

Delivers clear and engaging video reviews with good pacing and clarity

Level 2

Delivers video reviews with some engagement, clarity, or organization

Level 1

Delivers video reviews with limited clarity, poor pacing, or minimal engagement

Application
Criteria: How effectively does the student apply their custom rating criteria consistently across 5 different biography/autobiography options to select a final text?
Level 4

Applies the rating criteria with a high degree of consistency and effectiveness across all 5 options

Level 3

Applies the rating criteria with considerable consistency and effectiveness across most options

Level 2

Applies the rating criteria with some consistency across the options

Level 1

Applies the rating criteria with limited consistency